My husband and I stumbled into Santa Lucia one night after arriving in Florence. The staff was extremely friendly and made us feel right at home. It was a local spot and we enjoyed observing as people continued to come by and say hi to the staff.
We ordered the ravioli with meat sauce and a ham, red pepper and mozzarella pizza. After 10 days in Italy, including Rome, Florence and Venice, this was our favorite meal of the trip. We made sure to stop by once more before leaving town.
To add another data point other reviews mentioned prices being high but we thought the price was fantastic compared to other places more easily found by tourists.GooglePlace - August 2017
Wonderful pizza! Low-key casual atmosphere and seems to be popular with the locals.GooglePlace - May 2017
First night in Florence, googled where to eat locally and this popped up. Glad it did... Excellent food at reasonable prices, fantastic service. Actually... The best Pizza I've had in Italy so far and we've eaten everywhere except Napoli. Enjoy :) GooglePlace - November 2016
Ottima pizza e pesce, ambiente sempliceFoursquare - September 2015
Amazing restaurant.If you are not realy hungry do not come inside.And don't ask what's better.Everithing is very delicious! Grazie GooglePlace - June 2015
Очень вежливый официант. Не включил в счет разлитый по нашей вине напиток.Foursquare - May 2015
Pizza buona prezzi decenti ma nn superiore alla fama che si è fatta negli anni cercate cercate ancora che locali nn mancano fermatevi solo se nn avete più fantasia o risorse migliori :)))Foursquare - April 2013
ottimo il pesce, specie il polpo lessoFoursquare - January 2013