Mustafio's Pizza / San Francisco

1116 Polk St at Post St San Francisco 94109
Opening Hours
Sun, Mon, Tue, Wed, Thu 11:00 - 02:00
Fri, Sat 11:00 - 03:00
average 424 votes
Tips from the Net @ Mustafio's Pizza
Patrick Cahel en
When I complained about my order, they made it right immediately. I was very happy with that. When I have been here on previous occasions, both the service and food were very good. GooglePlace - August 2017
Scott Anderson en
Order for delivery. Took an hour to get the pizza as the driver got lost and called twice. Pizza was very good as well as the cheesey bread. GooglePlace - August 2017
Joe Cortes Graphic Designs en
Incredible tasty flavorful Pizza. This is one of the freshest most delicious Pizza I've eaten in awhile. The place is small, very few tables but it has character and the pizza is awesome. I'm sure you'll love it as well. GooglePlace - July 2017
Emilio Aymat en
I came in with a hunger after drinking quite a lot and I ended up getting a veggie slice which had tomato slices, feta and pesto and even though the pesto was passable and the tomatoes tasted fresh, the dough was horrible. It was soft and tasted undercooked. Pizza dough should be kinda crunchy and when u bite into a slice of pizza, it shouldn't taste like ur eating uncooked dough, as the slices here GooglePlace - June 2017
Bianca M. Curutan en
Back to basics! I came here as a Yelp Elite, and was definitely not disappointed. I had two square slices (one with just cheese and one with cheese and pepperoni). It was nothing fancy which was perfect since I was craving a quick, casual bite without all the frills that some pizza places have. The crust was crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, just the way I like it; and not too thick nor too thin. The pizza in general was awesome and it wasn't too salty or too greasy. The service was friendly quick, and the restaurant itself was small-ish but with a good number of high tables and bar seating. Overall, I had a great experience with the food and customer service and i look forward to coming back again (or ordering delivery) and maybe throw in one of their desserts next time ;) GooglePlace - May 2017